My Personal Recruiter Review [Cost + Customer Reviews]

So, you need help with your job search and you’re considering hiring an agency to help bridge the gap.

You’ve possibly heard about My Personal Recruiter’s reverse recruiting services and are wondering if they’re worth the investment.

You’ve come to the right place! We will review My Personal Recruiter and their managed job search services.

We have taken a deep dive into the customer reviews, cost, services offered, and staff at My Personal Recruiter. Our overall rating for My Personal Recruiter is 60/100.

Our goal is to help you find the best service that will advance your career. Take a look at some of our top-rated reverse recruiting services and find the perfect fit for you!

About My Personal Recruiter

My Personal Recruiter was very recently founded by Adam Fineberg in 2023. With its headquarters in Miami, Florida, this company dedicates itself to helping job seekers connect with employers across the globe.

To achieve this, the company offers reverse recruiting, outplacement, and career coaching services. Here, we will focus on the company’s reverse recruiting services.

My Personal Recruiter provides an affordable solution to reverse recruiting services. Because of the low cost though, some key parts of a successful job search are missing from their offerings. 

Applications are completed by employees outside of the United States and no networking is done on your behalf, unlike more comprehensive and personalized reverse recruiting services. 

So at the end of the day, this affordable service may not be any more effective than quick-applying for jobs on your own.

My Personal Recruiter Pros & Cons

As with any company, there are pros and cons. It’s up to you to determine what is a “must-have” and what things you can live without.

PROS

• Founder has nearly a decade of recruiting experience
• Team members have resume writing and coaching certifications
• Customer ratings average 5 stars
• Job seekers can monitor their job search from a portal

CONS

• Expensive for the service level
• Company started in 2023
• Job applications are completed outside of US
• Job seekers do their own networking

If you are looking for a career service provider, My Personal Recruiter is a great option, but it is worth considering other alternatives to find the best fit for your needs.

One such alternative is Find My Profession. Find My Profession, like My Personal Recruiter, has a customer rating of over 4.9/5 stars and provides a hands-free job application process.

Unlike My Personal Recruiter, Find My Profession possesses far more reverse recruiting experience and takes care of essential networking tasks on your behalf. Additionally, Find My Profession holds the distinction of being the pioneering and most comprehensive reverse recruiting service available in the market.

My Personal Recruiter Customer Reviews

Our career experts have rated My Personal Recruiter a 60/100. Additionally, My Personal Recruiter has received a 5/5 rating on Google.

Google displays 21 reviews with an average rating of 5/5 for My Personal Recruiter. Upon closer look, the majority of the reviews lack detailed information about the services provided.

While the overall customer rating appears impressive, the limited number of reviews and lack of substantial information make it challenging to fully trust the rating.

But as with anything, it’s important to take each review with a grain of salt. Additional research should be done beyond reading the reviews that are found online.

In contrast to My Personal Recruiter’s sparse reviews, Find My Profession has a ton of reviews from previous clients. Their average rating is 4.9/5 stars based on the experiences of 900+ clients.

How Much Does My Personal Recruiter Cost?

My Personal Recruiter charges $799 – $1,999 per month for their reverse recruiting services. This is on the high end since the services provided are pretty basic.

The price is somewhat high for a service that doesn’t provide clients with the most comprehensive reverse recruiting experience. Upon evaluating their offerings, we identified some shortcomings that you should consider.

First, the service lacks full networking support. While an ideal reverse recruiting service would network on your behalf, these professionals only provide networking guidance (with their top-tier package) – the rest is left to you.

Second, the amount of time dedicated to your job search each week is minimal, which does not align well with the concept of reverse recruiting and managing your job search on your behalf.

Third, customized resumes and cover letters are restricted to the more expensive plans. It’s worth noting that the mid-tier plan allows for only two customized resumes per month.

Lastly, the basic service lacks interview preparation and salary negotiation support. These crucial aspects are only included in the higher-tier plans.

This lack of comprehensive support may prolong your job search, which contradicts the purpose of investing in a premium job search service.

One thing to keep in mind is that My Personal Recruiter is not a recruiting or staffing agency. They are not headhunters. They work as reverse recruiters which means they work directly for the job seeker.

So yes, the $799+ per month price tag would be paid by you upfront (not after you get hired).

For the most accurate and up-to-date details on package pricing at My Personal Recruiter, we recommend that you visit their website directly.

My Personal Recruiter Process

My Personal Recruiter has a straightforward process for their reverse recruiting service.

Create Account: The process starts by visiting their website and registering for an account.

Subscribe: Choose a reverse recruiting plan that aligns with your requirements. Opt for either the Basic, Standard, or Premium subscription, based on the features that best suit your needs.

Complete Onboarding: After selecting your plan, finalize the onboarding process to kickstart your journey.

Improve Professional Branding: The resume writer will create a customized resume that can be adjusted to fit the criteria of each job application, depending on your package.

Receive Coaching: Coaching plays a crucial role in My Personal Recruiter’s reverse recruiting approach. Depending on your selected subscription, your career coach and reverse recruiter will furnish you with a tailored job search strategy and impart essential skills for interviews, negotiation, and networking.

My Personal Recruiter Team

The company’s website fails to provide any details regarding the team members or their qualifications. Fortunately, through research on their LinkedIn page, we uncovered some insights about the team.

The team at My Personal Recruiter comprises professionals proficient in career coaching, social media management, resume writing, and reverse recruiting. Notably, nine team members specialize in reverse recruiting.

Conversely, the team exhibits limited experience in the realm of reverse recruiting. This is evidenced by the absence of substantial reverse recruiting expertise on their individual LinkedIn profiles.

Moreover, it seems that these reverse recruiters do not solely concentrate on reverse recruiting. Many of them hold multiple roles within the company, with some even engaging in entirely different responsibilities.

It’s worth mentioning that a majority of the team members are based outside the US, potentially indicating a lack of familiarity with their clients’ local job markets.

Additionally, the My Personal Recruiter team includes two career coaches. One is affiliated with the International Coaching Federation (ICF), while the other holds the title of Certified Empowerment and Motivational Professional (CEMP). Despite the website referencing a Certified Professional Career Coach (CPCC), we could not identify any coach with this specific certification.

The resume writing aspect of their process may be managed by Rock My Resume, a company also established by Adam Fineberg.

Is My Personal Recruiter Worth It?

Whether or not My Personal Recruiter is worth it is entirely up to you.

Our goal is to provide you with the most transparent and helpful information possible. But, only you know what is best for you and your career.

Here is a summary of our findings on My Personal Recruiter:

• Customer Reviews: 10/25
• Cost to Value: 15/25
• Time Savings: 20/25
• Team Knowledge: 15/25
• Total Score: 60/100

We highly recommend reviewing 2-3 services before making a final decision.

If you’re in need of a fully managed job search service, we suggest checking out Find My Profession. With a team of experienced reverse recruiters and a commitment to customer satisfaction, Find My Profession can help you find your dream job. And with a perfect score of 100/100, you can trust that you’ll be in good hands!